Say What? Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jerry O’Connell Used to Date!

Sarah Michelle Gellar, 44, and Jerry O'Connell, 47, once DATED after meeting in high school

Sarah Michelle Gellar & Jerry O'Connell Reminisce About When They Dated After Going to High School Together

Sarah Michelle Gellar ‘Found Strength’ In Voicing Teela In ‘Masters Of The Universe’ Reboot: ‘It Was Incredible’