Mariah Carey, Nick Cannon’s Twins Join Singer at Macy’s Day Parade

Mariah Carey Closes Out Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade With “All I Want For Christmas Is You”

Mariah Carey BLASTED by fans for 'blatant lip-syncing' during Thanksgiving Day parade

Mariah Carey RETURNS to Thanksgiving Day parade - as fans BLAST star for 'blatant lip-syncing'