Hailey and Justin Bieber bundle up in padded jackets as they head for New Year's Day lunch in Aspen

Shakira takes a subtle swipe at ex Gerard Piqué in New Year's Day post

Judge Judy Says She's Happy for Justin Bieber's Growth After Calling Him Foolish

Selena Gomez snuggles with new besties Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz during New Year's holiday