Joe Manganiello and Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor Celebrate Anniversary
Joe Manganiello, Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor Enjoy Red Carpet Outing
Joe Manganiello Shows Off His Tattooed Muscles During Day Out with Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O'Connor 'were forced to talk about having kids' after his ex Sofia Vergara claimed they divorced over her not wanting more children
Joe Manganiello Not Dating Caitlin O'Connor Just For Chance to Have Kids
Joe Manganiello, 47, and girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor, 34, hold hands as they stroll in New York City
Joe Manganiello's girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor flashes her abs in a black sports bra as they leave gym session
Joe Manganiello looks relaxed after a workout with girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor on the same day his divorce is finalized from ex Sofia Vergara
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O'Connor's Relationship Timeline
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O'Connor Planning for Marriage and Kids: Source
Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O' Connor's Relationship 'Is Serious,' They're 'Excited About the Future' (Source)
Joe Manganiello cradles his beloved dog Bubbles in one arm as he and girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor enjoy post-workout stroll in Venice
Joe Manganiello goes Instagram official with Caitlin O'Connor - just weeks after finalizing Sofia Vergara divorce
Joe Manganiello Makes Caitlin O'Connor Romance Instagram Official
Joe Manganiello Goes Instagram Official With Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor
Sofia Vergara's ex Joe Manganiello, 47, 'MOVES IN' with new girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor, 34 - after settling divorce from Modern Family actress
Joe Manganiello's GF Caitlin O'Connor Moves in with Him After Sofia Vergara Divorce
Joe Manganiello, 47, lets girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor, 33, carry his dog Bubbles in Los Angeles... after ex-wife Sofia Vergara talked her dating life
Joe Manganiello Steps Out with Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor Amid Ex Sofia Vergara's Comments About Their Split
Joe Manganiello, 47, displays youthful hair makeover as he steps out with girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor, 33 - after ex Sofia Vergara opened up about split
