Did Chad Michael Murray Cheat on Erin Foster With Sophia Bush? Inside Their Relationship Timelines

Hilarie Burton Clears the Air About Chad Michael Murray Cheating on Erin Foster With Sophia Bush

Biggest Stories of the Week (From Britney Spears' Abortion Revelation to Sophia Bush's Rumored New Romance)

Hilarie Burton comes to 'sister' Sophia Bush's defense after Erin Foster's Chad Michael Murray cheating claims