Bachelor In Paradise: Katie Thurston makes surprise arrival on beach and shocks ex-fiancee Blake Moynes and his new love interest Jess Girod
Katie Thurston Says Ex Blake Moynes Looked ‘Like He Saw a Ghost’ on ‘BiP’
Bachelor in Paradise season nine cast revealed: Former Bachelorette Rachel Recchia and Blake Moynes are among contestants heading to Mexico as they attempt to find love on TV for the THIRD time
